About Cast and Countered

We're a two-person shop built for Magic players, by Magic players. Every card we sell has passed through our hands and our grading loupes.

Owner One

Co-founder · Head Buyer

Has been slinging cards since Urza's block. Runs our singles desk and obsesses over condition grading. Favorite color: Gruul.

Co-founder · Events & Community

Organizes our weekly Commander nights and prerelease events. Loves brewing janky Dimir mill decks that nobody asked for.

Every single is graded by hand — no surprises on arrival.
Sealed product is stored in a climate-controlled room.
We run weekly events: Commander, Draft, and a casual "kitchen table" night for new players.
If something's wrong with your order, email us — we make it right.